Illegal 'Convenience Fees' Charged by HOA Management Companies: A Threat to Consumer Rights

Imagine receiving a surprise charge on your homeowners' association (HOA) dues statement, labeled as a "convenience fee" for paying electronically. You might feel frustrated, especially if you didn't consent to this additional cost. Unfortunately, this scenario is a reality for many Floridian homeowners who have been unfairly charged by HOA management companies. A recent class action lawsuit filed in the Southern District of Florida aims to put an end to this unlawful practice and protect consumers' rights.

‍

What are "Convenience Fees"?

The term "convenience fee" might sound harmless, but it's actually a euphemism for an unauthorized charge. HOA management companies, such as Development Consultants, Inc. and Associations, Inc., have been adding these fees to homeowners' dues payments made electronically via ACH, credit card, or debit card. These fees range between 2.5% to 3.5% of the total dues amount and are allegedly intended to cover the cost of processing electronic payments. However, the plaintiffs argue that these fees are not only unauthorized but also a clear violation of Florida consumer protection laws.

‍

Violation of Florida Consumer Protection Laws

The Florida Consumer Collection Practices Act (FCCPA) and the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act (FDUTPA) prohibit the collection of unauthorized fees. The plaintiffs claim that the defendants never obtained proper authorization from homeowners to charge these fees, nor did they disclose them clearly. The law requires that any additional charges must be explicitly stated in the contract or agreement. Since these fees were not agreed upon by the homeowners, they are considered unlawful.

‍

The lawsuit also invokes common law, arguing that the defendants have a fiduciary duty to act in the best interests of the homeowners they serve. By charging unauthorized fees, the defendants have breached this duty and acted in their own self-interest.

‍

Damages and Jurisdiction

The lawsuit seeks damages for the plaintiffs and class members, who are Floridian residents that have paid these unlawful fees over the past four years. The court has subject matter jurisdiction due to the amount involved and the presence of diverse parties among the defendants and class members. Venue is appropriate because many of the events took place within the district.

‍

The plaintiffs are seeking restitution for the unlawfully collected fees, as well as punitive damages to deter future misconduct by the defendants. The lawsuit also aims to enjoin the defendants from continuing this practice, ensuring that no further harm is done to consumers.

‍

Impact on Consumers

The impact of these illegal fees extends beyond the financial burden. Homeowners who pay their HOA dues electronically may feel forced to pay these fees to avoid late charges or penalties. This could lead to a snowball effect, where homeowners are more likely to fall behind on their payments or face financial hardship. The defendants' actions have not only violated consumer protection laws but also threatened the financial stability of homeowners in Florida.

‍

Stand up if you've been affected

Stop Consumer Harm is a secure platform where you can safely report corporate wrongdoing. We are here for you. Let us know what's happened and we will be right there to support you.

Email Address

Tell us your bit of the story

We've successfully received your secure message

Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form. Please refresh and try again or email us at support@stopconsumerharm.com

‍

Conclusion

The class action lawsuit against Development Consultants, Inc., Associations, Inc., and Hoam Ventures, Inc. highlights the need for stronger consumer protection laws and enforcement. It's unacceptable for HOA management companies to take advantage of homeowners by charging unauthorized fees, hiding behind the guise of "convenience." The court must hold these defendants accountable for their actions and ensure that they refund the unlawfully collected fees to the affected homeowners.

‍

If you're a homeowner in Florida who has paid these illegal fees, you may be eligible to join the class action lawsuit. Don't hesitate to seek legal advice and exercise your consumer rights. Together, we can put an end to this unethical practice and protect our community from further harm.